Blogs

church insurance episcopal

Catholic Church & Parish Insurance

Most Catholic parishes don’t buy insurance on their own. Their diocese insures them through a diocesan program, and the parish pays its share. Knowing how that program works tells you what’s already covered and where a parish, school or Catholic organization still needs coverage of its own. This guide explains the three ways dioceses usually insure parishes, the gaps those programs leave, which Catholic organizations buy their own coverage, and what’s changing in the market.

How Dioceses Insure Their Parishes

Dioceses usually use one of three setups:

  • A diocesan self-insurance program. The diocese pays claims from its own fund up to a set level and buys excess insurance above it for large catastrophes. Each parish pays a premium based on its exposure.
  • A pooled program through Catholic Mutual Group. Catholic Mutual is a nonprofit, founded in 1889, that insures only Church-owned institutions and serves more than 125 dioceses and archdioceses. Many dioceses belong to its self-insured pools.
  • Diocesan master policies with commercial carriers. Some dioceses place property, auto, workers’ comp or crime under master policies covering every parish.

These programs are broad. One diocesan program, for example, covers buildings and contents, general liability, D&O, employment practices, sexual misconduct liability, auto, workers’ comp, cyber, crime, flood and earthquake for all its parishes and agencies.

What this means for a parish

If your parish is part of a diocesan program, your coverage, limits and deductibles are set by the diocese, not chosen by the parish. The parish’s job is to understand the program, report property values and activities accurately, follow the diocese’s safety requirements, and fill the gaps the program doesn’t cover. The diocese’s risk manager or insurance office is the first call for questions about your coverage.

What Diocesan Programs Usually Leave Out

Even a broad program has gaps a parish should know about:

  • Personal vehicles. Volunteers and staff driving their own cars need their own auto coverage; one diocese requires at least $100,000/$300,000 liability limits for private vehicles used on Church business.
  • Deductibles. Parishes typically pay the first part of each loss themselves (one program excludes the first $2,500 of each property loss).
  • Common property exclusions such as wear and tear, mold, settling and mechanical breakdown.
  • Outside groups using parish facilities. Renters and event hosts are generally expected to carry their own liability insurance and name the parish as additional insured.

Check your diocese’s insurance manual or ask its risk manager for the details of your program.

Parish Events, Festivals and Facility Use

Parish life brings in many people who aren’t parishioners: festival crowds, wedding guests, families at funerals, sports leagues, AA meetings, community groups and vendors. Each one adds liability exposure, and how your diocese handles it depends on its program. Before a large event or a new facility-use arrangement, check:

  • Whether the diocesan program covers the event as written, or requires notice or approval for large events, alcohol, rides or fireworks
  • Whether vendors, caterers and ride operators must show their own liability insurance and name the parish as additional insured
  • Whether the outside group renting the hall has a signed facility-use agreement and a certificate of insurance on file
  • Whether volunteers driving to an event are using their own cars, which their personal auto policies cover first

Keeping certificates of insurance on file for every outside group and vendor is one of the simplest ways a parish can protect itself and its diocese.

A Parish Insurance Checklist

Whether your parish is inside a diocesan program or not, these steps keep coverage working when you need it:

  1. Get a copy of your diocese’s insurance manual and know who to call to report a claim.
  2. Review the property values reported for each building, including the church, rectory, school and hall, at least every few years.
  3. Keep records of roof, electrical, plumbing and alarm updates.
  4. Make sure every staff member and volunteer who works with minors has completed the diocese’s screening and safe environment training.
  5. Confirm that staff and volunteers who drive on parish business carry the minimum auto limits your diocese requires.
  6. Collect certificates of insurance from every outside group, vendor and contractor.
  7. Report new programs, buildings and vehicles to the diocese before they start, not after a claim.

When Catholic Organizations Need Their Own Coverage

Some Catholic organizations sit outside a diocesan program and buy coverage directly:

  • Independent Catholic schools and academies
  • Religious orders and institutes, depending on how they’re organized
  • Catholic nonprofits, charities and apostolates that aren’t diocesan entities
  • Groups that rent parish halls or hold events on parish property

These organizations need the same core coverage as any church or nonprofit:

  • Property for buildings, contents and equipment, insured at replacement cost.
  • General liability for injuries to visitors and students.
  • Abuse and molestation coverage for any organization that works with children, usually with written screening and supervision policies required. See abuse and molestation insurance.
  • Directors and officers (D&O) for the board or council. See D&O insurance for churches and nonprofits.
  • Workers’ compensation for employees and, in some states, certain volunteers.
  • Commercial auto for owned vans and buses, plus hired and non-owned auto for staff and volunteers using their own cars.

Schools add student accident coverage and educators’ legal liability; see private school insurance.

What’s Changing in the Market

Religious organizations of every tradition have faced rising property insurance costs since 2023. Severe storms, wildfires and higher rebuilding costs have pushed up property claims, and the largest church insurers have tightened underwriting and dropped some churches they consider high risk. Some congregations have seen renewals rise several-fold.

For parishes inside a diocesan program, those costs can show up as higher parish assessments or larger deductibles rather than a carrier’s renewal notice. For Catholic schools, orders and nonprofits that buy their own coverage, they show up directly at renewal, which makes it more important to keep building values current, document maintenance and compare quotes from more than one carrier. For more on what drives religious organizations’ premiums, see how much church insurance costs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who insures Catholic churches?

Most Catholic parishes are insured through their diocese, either by a diocesan self-insurance program, a pooled program through Catholic Mutual Group, or master policies the diocese places with commercial carriers.

Does Catholic Mutual insure parishes directly?

Catholic Mutual insures Church-owned institutions, and many dioceses insure their parishes through its self-insured pools. A parish’s coverage is usually arranged through its diocese rather than purchased separately by the parish.

Can a Catholic school or religious order buy its own insurance?

Yes. Independent Catholic schools, many religious orders, and Catholic nonprofits that aren’t diocesan entities often buy coverage directly from carriers that write religious organizations and schools.

Does a group renting our parish hall need its own insurance?

Generally, yes. Most parishes and dioceses expect outside groups to carry their own liability insurance and name the parish as an additional insured. Check your diocese’s facility-use policy for its specific requirements.

Who We Are

Integrity Now Insurance Brokers is an independent insurance agency based in Long Beach, California, that specializes in churches, religious organizations and nonprofits. As an independent broker, we aren’t tied to one carrier: we compare coverage from multiple carriers that write religious organizations, schools and nonprofits. We’re licensed in California (license #0D42517) and in other states.

If your Catholic school, religious order, ministry or nonprofit buys its own coverage, or you want a second opinion on a renewal, we can help. Request a quote or call us at (877) 854-7396. Learn more about our insurance for religious organizations, or see how we cover Episcopal churches and dioceses and Presbyterian parishes.

Sources

Accessibility Toolbar

Scroll to Top