Blogs

d&o insurance for nonprofit board members

How Much D&O Insurance Does a Nonprofit Need?

Most small nonprofits and churches start with a $1 million directors and officers (D&O) limit. Organizations with employees, significant assets or programs that handle other people’s money often need more. The right limit depends on how much a lawsuit against your board could realistically cost to defend and settle, and on how your policy’s limit gets used up. This guide covers how to size that limit. For what D&O covers and why boards need it, see our main page on directors and officers insurance for churches and nonprofits.

Where Most Nonprofits Start: $1 Million

A $1 million limit is the usual starting point for small organizations, and it’s inexpensive. Nonprofits Insurance Alliance, an insurer that specializes in nonprofits, has published that an organization with no employees can buy $1 million in D&O limits for around $600 a year. Churches and religious organizations that request quotes through Insureon pay a median of $854 a year for D&O.

At Integrity Now Insurance Brokers, $1,000,000 is the standard D&O limit we place for the churches and nonprofits we insure. It’s the right fit for most small and mid-size organizations, and often enough for a small, all-volunteer organization with a modest budget. It’s a floor, not a recommendation for everyone. The questions below tell you whether you need more.

What a D&O Claim Actually Costs

Nonprofits Insurance Alliance’s claims data gives a sense of scale for smaller nonprofits:

  • About 1 in 25 nonprofits has a D&O claim in a given year.
  • The average claim costs about $35,000 to resolve.
  • About 1 in 10 claims costs more than $100,000.

Those figures come from an insurer’s own book of business and were first published in 2008, so treat them as a rough guide. Legal costs have risen since then. The point that holds up is that most claims are manageable, but a meaningful share are large, and the large ones are what your limit is for.

Six Questions That Set Your Limit

  1. Do you have employees? Employment claims (wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment) are the most common D&O claims for nonprofits. Industry figures put the employment-related share anywhere from about two-thirds to 95 percent of claims. Once you have even one employee, D&O with employment practices coverage is close to essential, and more employees justify a higher limit.
  2. Does employment practices liability (EPL) share the D&O limit? Many nonprofit policies combine D&O and EPL under one limit. If they do, a single employment claim can use up the protection your board needs for everything else. A separate EPL limit, or a higher shared limit, fixes that.
  3. Are defense costs inside or outside the limit? Legal fees are a large share of D&O losses. When defense costs sit inside the limit, every dollar spent on lawyers reduces what’s left for a settlement. A policy that pays defense outside the limit effectively gives you more protection for the same stated limit.
  4. How much money flows through board decisions? Endowments, building campaigns, grants, investment funds and large contracts raise the stakes of a board decision, and a claim over a failed investment or a misused restricted gift can be larger than a typical employment claim.
  5. Who could sue you? Employees, donors, members, beneficiaries, vendors and government regulators can all bring claims against a board. The more of these relationships you have, the more ways a claim can start.
  6. Could your organization survive one claim without coverage? Compare the limit to your annual budget and reserves. A limit that covers a realistic worst case keeps one lawsuit from threatening the mission.

When to Consider More Than $1 Million

There’s no fixed rule tying a limit to a budget, but these situations usually justify moving above $1 million, often to $2 million or more:

Situation Why it raises your limit
Paid staff, especially 10 or more employees More employment decisions mean more employment claims, the most common D&O loss.
EPL shares the D&O limit One employment claim can use up the limit the board needs for everything else.
Defense costs are inside the limit Legal fees reduce what’s left to pay a settlement.
Endowment, investment funds or a capital campaign Claims over investment and spending decisions can be large.
School, daycare or other regulated programs Regulatory and parent claims add new ways for a claim to start.
Board members with significant personal assets Directors want enough protection that their own assets aren’t at risk.

Larger organizations sometimes add an excess policy on top of their primary D&O, or a Side A policy that protects individual directors when the organization can’t indemnify them.

Policy Terms That Matter as Much as the Limit

  • Side A, B and C. Side A protects individual directors and officers when the organization can’t indemnify them, Side B reimburses the organization when it does, and Side C covers the organization itself when it’s named in a suit. Make sure your policy includes all three.
  • Claims-made coverage. D&O covers claims first made while the policy is in force. If you switch carriers or let coverage lapse, ask about prior-acts coverage so earlier board decisions stay covered.
  • Exclusions. Policies typically exclude fines, penalties, taxes and amounts owed under a contract. D&O also can’t cover board members’ responsibility for payroll taxes and retirement contributions that were withheld but never paid.
  • Deductible. A higher deductible lowers the premium, but your organization pays that amount on every claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much D&O insurance should a small nonprofit have?

Most small nonprofits start at $1 million. An all-volunteer organization with a small budget may never need more. Add limit as you add employees, assets and programs, and check whether employment claims share that limit.

Is $1 million in D&O coverage enough?

For many small organizations, yes. It may not be enough if you have several employees, if EPL and defense costs both come out of the same $1 million, or if your board oversees significant funds.

Should a church carry the same D&O limit as other nonprofits?

The same questions apply. A church with paid staff, a school or daycare, or a building campaign has the same exposures as any nonprofit with those features and should size its limit the same way.

Does a higher D&O limit cost much more?

Usually less than you’d expect, because premiums don’t rise in proportion to the limit. Get quotes at two limits, such as $1 million and $2 million, to see the difference for your organization.

Get the Right Limit

An independent broker can compare limits, defense-cost terms and EPL options across carriers. Learn more about directors and officers insurance for churches, read Nonprofit Board Member Liability: A D&O Guide, or see examples of nonprofit D&O claims.

Sources

Accessibility Toolbar

Scroll to Top