Church Insurance New York

Picture1 17

New York Church Insurance Agency

It has been estimated that there are roughly 4100 religions practiced by people worldwide. Even if not all, you’re likely to find many of them in the diverse, world-renowned metropolitan city, New York. Estimates show that nearly 60% of the total population of the Big Apple includes practicing Christians. Undoubtedly, New Yorkers are devout servants of God.


As one of the most iconic locations in the world, New York is one of the fastest-growing cities in the United States, both in terms of population, visitors, and opportunities. The hustle and bustle in the city that never sleeps, coupled with an overcrowded population with different lifestyles, make the city stand out.



Some people enjoy the city’s famous Broadway shows while others enjoy dining and shopping. The historic neighborhoods, Central Park, Brooklyn Bridge, Empire State Building, the Statue of Liberty, and similar landmarks garner the most attention.


But historians and art buffs can also find extensive libraries, museums, churches, and cathedrals with a rich history in the City of Dreams.  


The phantasmagoric skies, rich culture, inimitable art, and almost-mythical eccentricity serve a collective role in mesmerizing every person who visits the Fun City. Locals and people from all over the world visit New York’s ministries and churches in search of divine guidance and spiritual ablution.


Churches in New York are dedicated organizations known for their endless work for the community. These houses of worship serve as a radical escape for people seeking emotional and mental support, marginalized communities, the disabled, the needy, and the homeless. Churches fund several rehabilitation programs for those suffering from substance abuse problems and organize youth outreach programs, community meals, domestic and international evangelical missions, and host many events for the betterment of the community.


Churches in New York also serve as a haven for people with disabilities, destitution, and those who are homeless and dealing with substance abuse problems. People from far away cities seek spiritual guidance and emotional support from reverential church leaders and rely on their counseling to help them reconnect with their souls. Some ministries also rent out their facilities for large-scale events like weddings, funerals, wakes, baptisms, christenings, and vigils, and even organize national and international missionary trips.


Churches in New York indulge in many personal and legal activities every day. With the rising litigious culture and crime rates, church leaders have a great responsibility on their shoulders to protect the church community, employees, volunteers, pastors, and clergy from potential hazards and liabilities. In this litigious world, churches are frequently sued by employees and volunteers for wrongful terminations, theft, vandalism, property damage, bodily injuries, structural damages, claims of sexual misconduct, etc.


Churches have vast facilities since they receive a lot of charitable donations from organizations and community members. They often acquire expensive furniture, office equipment, and educational props used regularly during their services. Even catastrophic events like storms, floods, burglaries, shootings, vandalism, accidents, or break-ins can have disastrous consequences. Church leaders often end up paying excessive out-of-pocket expenses to save their organization.

How Can Ministries in New York Streamline Maximum Protection from Liabilities?

Churches require sturdy risk management strategies that ensure their ministry is always safe in the face of any cataclysmic event. Every church leader must prioritize investing in a suitable church insurance policy that meets all of their operation’s specific needs and requirements.

However, finding a reliable church insurance plan can be challenging. With so many options available, finding an optimized church insurance plan within your budget is not as simple as one might think. This is why our church insurance agents at Integrity Now Insurance Brokers offer highly tailored insurance policies to provide maximum protection for you and your church.

Picture6 13

Our insurance agents have years of experience in the insurance industry and are aware of all the different kinds of liability and litigation claims that can impact nonprofits and ministries. We devise proper church insurance policies and recommend additional endorsements to safeguard your church.


Our certified insurance agents will guide you line by line through different insurance plans and help you find the one that aligns perfectly with your operation. We will highlight all the risks surrounding your ministry and help you formulate an insurance plan to shield your operation from liability claims.


We will connect you to the nation’s top-tier church insurance companies and help you find the most suitable insurance policies at competitive rates. We make sure to go the extra mile for our clients, help them streamline the most reliable insurance policies, and safeguard their operations.


Whether your church is a fledgling start-up or a well-established organization, our specialist agents can help you get adequate coverage for church assets, ministry leaders, and community members.


Your protection is our priority. With our deep knowledge of the industry’s dynamics and complexities, you are in safe hands. To get tailored church insurance policies, reach out to us today! You can compare quotes and get personalized insurance plans at competitive rates by simply giving us a call!

Types of Church Liability Insurance Policies Available for Your Ministry in New York

Picture5 15

Churches in New York aren’t just structures worth admiring but serve a higher purpose. These churches are places of spiritual growth, fellowship, finding solace, and safe refuge.


However, since many churches are running on a tight budget, they require specialized insurance policies to avoid potential litigation and liabilities that can become a huge financial drain.


This is why every church leader needs to consider getting a coverage plan best suited to their needs and financial situation. Here are some of the different types of ministry insurance plans our independent church insurance brokers can help you out with.

Church Property Insurance in New York

Church property insurance can help protect your ministry’s financial health from disasters beyond your control. Water damage, growth of mold, leaking pipes, decay, storms, and fires could lead to structural damage that can increase the risk of collapsing. Vandalism, electrical surges, and other malicious activities can also lead to significant losses.


Regardless of factors like whether you own the building or are renting it to serve the community, your church’s denomination, or the size of your church, you need to optimize protection to ensure nothing impedes your congregation’s safety and growth.


Proper coverage by a reliable church insurance company can help keep your ministry afloat, regardless of the severity of the damage. But the key is to ensure the policy adequately covers all the valuables, equipment, structures, pews, artwork, stained glass, statues, and other essential elements for its operations. The policy should also cover your pastor’s belongings.


The coverage you need depends on several factors, so it’s best to discuss it with reliable church insurance agents before you trust any church insurance company in New York. We can help you determine which types of supplemental coverages you require and get the best value for the enhancements you request when upgrading your church insurance plans.


We can guide you towards streamlining the best ministry insurance plans to adequately protect your house of worship, affiliated schools, and denominational offices across New York.


Our church insurance brokers in New York will also help you understand the terms and other differences in policies offered by church insurance companies. We don’t want you to suffer when the claim gets denied because you signed up for church insurance without understanding what the policy covers and on what terms and conditions.

Employee Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI)

The EPLI coverage policy provides coverage for claims that arise from practices related to the employees. Any employee can accuse church members of age or gender discrimination, wrongful termination, negligence, harassment, and retaliation. But in that case, the EPLI policy will kick in and pay for attorney fees and any other liability claims.

Officers, Directors, and Trustees' Coverage

There are a lot of risks surrounding the administrative and financial decisions of the church. This is why church leaders must purchase the officers, directors, and trustees’ coverage plan to ensure church board members are safe from potential lawsuits, including financial decisions.

Auto Liability Insurance

A comprehensive commercial auto insurance policy and non-owned coverage provide adequate protection from accidents resulting on the road or church premises in privately owned or church-owned vehicles. The auto policy must also cover private vehicles used for church activities.  

Officers, Directors, and Trustees' Coverage

It covers the trustees, board of directors, and church officials from losses caused by liability claims. Officers, directors, and trustees’ coverage includes the financial decisions they make on behalf of the ministry.

Equipment Breakdown Insurance

Many churches in New York provide online sermons to stay connected with and reach new members. If you got an additional computer system, heating or cooling system, sound system, or other equipment, the Equipment Breakdown Policy helps reimburse the funds spent for replacements and repairs. You should also consider getting protection against cybercrimes if you deal with the sensitive personal data of your staff, members, clergy, volunteers, and so on.

General Church Liability Insurance

 General church liability insurance provides broad coverage to small and large entities alike. This coverage plan protects the church from two of the most common liability claims: property damage and bodily injuries from members, volunteers, clergy, and employees.


A church liability insurance policy will shield the church from any litigations related to its activities and operations. Whether your church is just a start-up or is a well-established organization, church leaders can be held responsible for any cases of injuries and accidents that take place during mass service.  


Without signing up for this coverage policy, your church will be vulnerable to several lawsuits and legal charges that can become a financial strain that is hard to overcome.


Consulting with a licensed church insurance agent will help you identify how vulnerable your organization is to any risks and what kind of insurance policy you should invest in that covers all the bases.

Worker's Compensation Insurance

The worker’s compensation insurance plan is mandated in New York. If any church employee sustains injuries on church premises, this insurance policy will cover their medical bills, lost wages, ongoing care bills, and even death benefits.

Abuse and Molestation Insurance Coverage

This coverage plan protects the church from alleged and actual claims of sexual misconduct. Regardless of whether your ministry was involved or blamed, the fees of legal defense for abuse and molestation charges can easily reach six figures. The policy provides sound coverage when sourced from a reliable church insurance company in New York.

Employee Theft Insurance

Since theft is fairly common across all businesses in New York, an employee theft insurance policy will safeguard your church whenever there is a case of theft, fraud, or embezzlement by bonded ministry employees.

Pastor's and Ministers' Liability Coverage

Churches can ensure maximum protection for their ministers and pastors by purchasing the pastor’s and ministers’ liability coverage plan.


Sometimes people can accuse church counselors and pastors of mental, physical, or emotional harm. This is where this coverage policy will prove useful.

Fire Insurance

Wildfires are becoming a common occurrence in New York, so it’s best to get a good fire insurance policy to prevent out-of-pocket expenses when it comes to rebuilding church-owned structures.


Fires are also very common in churches due to frequent candles in religious ceremonies. But with a reliable fire insurance policy, your church will have ample protection, so your operation will continue running smoothly.

Commercial Auto Insurance

Churches in New York often offer transportation facilities to regular churchgoers, seniors, minors, employees, and clergymen. Church-owned vehicles and rental cars require insurance if there are any accidental damages due to collisions, vandalism, break-ins, floods, and fires.


Hired and non-owned auto insurance is equally important, as every ministry will occasionally hire a non-owned, personal vehicle for church-related tasks. Whenever a person uses a vehicle not owned by the ministry to perform a church-related task, the ministry risks a claim. The policy is especially helpful when a ministry gets sued after an auto accident.

Why High-Risk Ministries Must Consider Investing in Umbrella Church Insurance

The umbrella coverage policy is a must-have layer of protection that you must add to your general liability coverage plan. This insurance policy provides extra protection to your organization in the case of an excessive liability claim.


This coverage plan will protect you if any church-owned vehicle gets into a serious accident, if any church board members are facing a hefty lawsuit, if anyone injures themselves on church premises, or if a neighboring building gets damaged because of a church-related accident.

Picture3 15

The umbrella insurance is very useful when your base insurance plan reaches its limit in a liability claim. For example, if your church is being sued for $400,000, and the general liability insurance is only paying for $300,000, the umbrella insurance policy will cover the shortfall of $100,000.

Other benefits of this insurance policy include coverage for wrongful prosecution or eviction, false arrests or imprisonment, libel, slander, defamation, and invasion of privacy.

What Makes Integrity Now Insurance Brokers the Top Choice for Ministries in New York?

Picture2 15

Obtaining adequate church liability or church property insurance isn’t as simple as calling the local broker to get a quote. You’ll need someone who specializes in the area so that you can get specific policies and coverage tailored to your ministry’s needs. 


Church insurance agents at Integrity Now Insurance Broker are well-experienced, licensed, and extremely professional. We do our best to devise an optimized insurance plan that ensures minimized risks of accidents and threats to your ministry.

Our process includes working with you to first identify the vulnerabilities that pose risks to your ministry. Then, we recommend a set of policies and coverages to be added to the risk management plan for your ministry.


We provide customized care covering every aspect of a church operation when helping you connect with insurance carriers offering unprecedented tailored insurance at the most competitive rates.


We’ve also got plenty of resources on our website for anyone looking to understand the complex industry jargon, statutory and compliance requirements, rights as a claimant, tips and tricks, guides, and a lot more that help make informed and profitable decisions.


Get in touch with us at any time to ask questions or convey your concerns regarding the church insurance claim process for our services in New York.

Accessibility Toolbar

Scroll to Top