Pastoral Counseling Guidelines For Churches

Pastoral Counseling Guidelines: How To Establish Biblical Counseling Guidelines For Pastoral Counseling At Church 

As your church ministry grows, many pastors may feel ill-equipped to provide Christian counseling to their church members. The American Association of Pastoral Counselors (AAPC) is a professional organization that promotes the development and delivery of spiritual counseling services.


As part of its commitment to quality care, the AAPC has developed Guidelines for Developing a Spiritual Counseling Program. A church board of directors must establish written professional counselor guidelines for your minister.  


These guidelines must assist those interested in developing and implementing a spiritual counseling program within their faith community or other settings.

How To Develop A Pastoral Counseling Guideline For Spiritual Care Of Church Members?

Step 1: Identify the need


In developing a pastoral counseling guideline for the spiritual care of church members, it is crucial to identify the need to provide adequate care and support. This involves actively listening to the member’s concerns and struggles and seeking to understand their unique situation and perspective.


Key factors to consider during this process include:


  1. The member’s spiritual background
  2. Current life circumstances,
  3. Any underlying emotional or mental health issues.


By identifying the need, pastors and counselors can tailor their approach to meet the specific needs of each individual, providing compassionate and effective care. It also lets them evaluate if a licensed therapist needs to be involved vs. spiritual guidance.


Step 2: Outline the spiritual counseling services required


When developing a pastoral counseling guideline for the spiritual care of church members, it is vital to outline the spiritual counseling services required. This process involves identifying the specific needs of the church community, determining the types of services that will be offered, and developing a plan for delivering these services effectively. 


Step 3: Develop an outline of qualifications and credentials requirements


Pastoral counselors must have a strong theology, counseling, and psychology foundation. A bachelor’s degree in theology or a related field is the minimum requirement, but a master’s or doctoral degree in counseling or psychology is preferred.


Pastoral must be ordained or licensed by a recognized religious organization. Pastoral counselors must undertake ongoing training to maintain their competence.


Pastoral counselors must adhere to ethical standards and be able to demonstrate their ability to provide spiritual care to church members. 


Step 4: Define performance standards and goals


When developing a pastoral counseling guideline for the spiritual care of church members, it is crucial to define clear and measurable performance standards and goals. These goals provide direction and serve as a benchmark for evaluating the counseling program’s effectiveness.


To ensure that the goals and standards are aligned with the overall mission and values of the church, it is essential to involve church leadership in developing and refining them.


Examples of performance standards that can be used to evaluate the counseling program’s effectiveness include the number of sessions attended by each member, the percentage of members who report a positive change in their spiritual well-being after counseling, and the percentage of members who recommend the counseling program to others.


Step 5: Develop measurable goals and indicators


Clear and measurable goals serve as a roadmap to guide the counseling process, and indicators help to track progress toward achieving these goals. To determine the indicators, it is essential to identify specific, observable, and measurable behaviors demonstrating progress toward the goals. 


For example, if the goal is to help a member overcome anxiety, indicators could include decreasing the frequency and intensity of panic attacks, improved sleep patterns, and increased participation in social activities.


By regularly evaluating these indicators, the effectiveness of the pastoral counseling program can be assessed, and adjustments can be made as necessary. 


Step 6: Create an action plan with milestones


Creating an action plan that spells out how long each task should take to complete is critical. 


Here is an example of an action plan with milestones:


  1. Research and review existing counseling guidelines – 2 weeks (Counseling Team)
  2. Identify critical areas of focus – 1 week (Pastor and Counseling Team)
  3. Develop a draft of the counseling guideline – 4 weeks (Counseling Team)
  4. Review and edit draft with feedback from church leaders and members – 2 weeks (Pastor and Counseling Team)
  5. Submit draft to legal team for approval or changes to comply with state laws – 1 week (Attorney)
  6. Finalize and publish the counseling guideline – 1 week (Pastor and Counseling Team)


Step 7: Implement the action plan


Once the finalized draft is complete, ensure that all pastors and counselors read the counseling guidelines and sign off that they will adhere to them.  


Step 8: Monitor progress and make adjustments as needed


Developing a pastoral counseling guideline for the spiritual care of church members requires regular evaluation to monitor progress and make adjustments as needed. The church board should identify new and relevant areas for improvement and implement changes necessary to ensure effective spiritual care is followed. 


Step 9: Establish guidelines for one on one spiritual counseling


Establishing guidelines for one-on-one spiritual counseling in pastoral counseling programs is crucial to ensure that counseling sessions are practical and grounded in the Bible and Christian principles.


Pastors should limit counsel to anyone no more than three times on the same issue and develop a relationship with a licensed Marriage and Family Therapist within the geographical area of the church for intense counseling cases.


When possible, counseling would be done with two church leaders or the Pastor’s spouse when counseling someone of the opposite sex.  


Rules and regulations, policy and guideline for employee to foll

What Are The Benefits Of Having Written Guidelines For Spiritual Counseling?

1. They help ensure the counseling services are of high quality.


Having written guidelines for spiritual counseling can ensure that the counseling services provided are of high quality. These guidelines can include information about the training and education required of pastoral counselors, the goals and objectives of the counseling program, and the requirements for satisfactory completion. 


2. They help to ensure all clients receive the same level of care.


Having written guidelines for spiritual counseling can help ensure that all clients receive the same level of care by promoting consistency in pastoral counseling. These guidelines outline the roles and responsibilities of all parties involved, the limits of confidentiality, and the steps that should be taken in potentially conflicting situations.


Guidelines can clarify the relationship between the pastoral counselor and each person in a group setting, such as spouses, parents, and children. Written guidelines can also help pastoral counselors delegate work to others, ensuring that only competent individuals are authorized to perform specific responsibilities. 


3. They help guarantee that the counseling services a church provides are up to date with current standards of care.


Having written guidelines for spiritual counseling can ensure that the counseling services provided by a church are up to date by providing clarity and structure to the counseling process. By establishing specific educational and certification requirements for those allowed to counsel, the church can ensure that the counselors are qualified and equipped to provide effective counseling services.


4. They allow for greater transparency between the church and its clients.


Written guidelines for spiritual counseling can promote transparency between the church and its clients by establishing clear expectations and boundaries for both the counselor and the client. These guidelines can include information on the following:


  • Nature and objectives of the services
  • The intended recipients
  • The counselor’s relationship with each person and the organization
  • The probable uses of services provided and information obtained
  • Who will have access to the information
  • Limits of confidentiality


5. They help ensure the church’s counseling services align with state laws.


It is essential to understand that counseling requires a degree and state license to put into practice. As a pastoral counselor, you should be aware of the potential risks and liabilities, and having written guidelines can help mitigate those risks.


In your church bylaws, you will want to establish who can give counseling and who cannot. This can include educational requirements and ordination.


It is best practice to have counseling individuals complete a background check. To avoid lawsuits for sexual abuse or misconduct, it is vital to keep counseling sessions as public as possible. This can include having counseling sessions in a public place or having another individual present during the session.


6. They provide structure and order to the counseling process.


Written guidelines for spiritual counseling provide structure and order to the counseling process by establishing clear roles and responsibilities for the counselor and the client. For example, at the outset of counseling, the pastoral counselor should describe the limits of confidentiality and the objectives of the counseling services.


This helps to establish trust between the counselor and the client and ensures that both parties know their obligations in the counseling process.


7. They help ensure the church does everything possible to protect its clients’ privacy.


Without guidelines, there is a risk that confidential information may be mishandled, intentionally or unintentionally, which can have severe consequences for clients. Guidelines can help mitigate this risk by establishing clear expectations and boundaries for counselors and clients, outlining how confidential information should be handled, stored, and shared. 


8. They increase the likelihood that counselors working for the church will be adequately trained.


Bylaws should be specifically tailored to the church’s needs and guide those who can counsel and cannot. Educational requirements and ordination can also be defined in the bylaws.


Pastoral counselors should undertake ongoing efforts to develop and maintain their competence, and reasonable steps should be taken to ensure that education and training programs meet the requirements for licensure, certification, or other goals.

Appropriate behavior

Top Ten Things To Do In Your First Pastoral Counseling Meeting

1. Agree On The Goal Of The Counseling Session


When meeting with someone for the first time for pastoral counseling, it is vital to agree on the goal of the counseling session. This will provide direction and focus for the rest of the sessions. 


2. Discuss Comfort Level And Confidentiality


To establish comfort level and confidentiality in the first pastoral counseling meeting, it is essential to have a transparent and open discussion about the limits of confidentiality and the foreseeable uses of the information generated through counseling activities. This discussion should occur at the outset of the relationship and thereafter as new circumstances may warrant.


3. Gather Information About The Client


In the first pastoral counseling meeting, gathering information about the client is essential to establish a therapeutic relationship. Pastoral counselors should inform clients about the nature and anticipated course of therapy, fees, involvement of third parties, and limits of confidentiality. 


4. Provide Information About The Counseling Process


During the first spiritual counseling session, the Pastor who will provide counseling services must clearly state the process. Let them know if they will have any homework, such as reading a specific book or taking notes on spiritual challenges they face throughout the week.  


Allow for Holy Spirit to guide you and the person you are counseling, and see how the Lord speaks to each of you.


5. Develop A Plan With The Client


Once you have established a relationship of trust and respect with your client, listen actively and empathetically to their concerns and feelings. Together, identify the issues that the client wants to address in counseling. This will help you set goals and objectives for the counseling process.


Collaboratively identify any obstacles that may arise during the counseling process. Examples of obstacles may include a lack of time or resources, personal beliefs, or negative self-talk.


When developing a plan of action, ensure it is biblically based, practical, and achievable. As you continue to meet with the church member, monitor the progress and adjust the action plan as necessary.


6. Identify Barriers To Success


In your first pastoral counseling meeting, it’s essential to identify potential barriers to success. These barriers may include fear, shame, or discomfort in discussing personal issues with a stranger.


7. Provide Insight Into The Counseling Approach


This can be done by actively listening to their concerns and using empathy to understand their perspective. The pastoral counselor should create a safe space for the counselee to share their struggles.


Incorporating spiritual guidance and support into counseling is essential by using scripture and prayer when appropriate. The pastoral counselor can encourage the counselee to deepen their relationship with God and seek His guidance. 


8. Set Up Regular Appointments


When meeting with clients for the first time, it’s essential to establish a regular meeting schedule to ensure consistent progress in counseling. While this may look different for some, the person being counseled needs to know you are available regularly.


9. Make Sure There Is Proper Oversight


Proper oversight in pastoral counseling is crucial to ensure the safety and well-being of those seeking help. Pastoral counselors must take reasonable steps to avoid delegating work to individuals with multiple relationships with those being served and only authorize responsibilities that can be performed competently.


Background checks are recommended, but talking to previous employers is essential to vet an individual’s qualifications thoroughly. In the first counseling meeting, it’s crucial to establish clear boundaries and expectations for confidentiality. 


10. Conduct Follow-Up After The Counseling Ends


Follow-up after a pastoral counseling session is crucial for the client’s well-being. Here are some steps to follow to conduct an effective follow-up:


  1. Schedule a follow-up session before the client leaves the initial session.
  2. Contact the client a few days after the initial session to check their progress.
  3. If the client is doing well, encourage them to continue implementing the strategies discussed in the initial session.
  4. If the client is not doing well, schedule another session as soon as possible or refer them to a licensed professional or emergency room.
  5. If unavailable, provide the client with trusted resources for further assistance.

Top 10 Things Not To Do During A Pastoral Counseling Meeting

1. Do not disclose confidential information


Confidentiality is a crucial aspect of pastoral counseling that should always be upheld. Pastoral counselors are bound by ethical and legal considerations to protect confidential information obtained during counseling sessions.


The counselor is not allowed to disclose confidential information that could lead to identifying the client/patient unless they have obtained prior consent or if the disclosure cannot be avoided. Pastoral counselors are only allowed to disclose information to the extent necessary to achieve the purposes of the consultation. 


2. Do not impose your values on the counseled


Pastoral counselors must avoid imposing their values on the counselee during counseling because it can negatively impact the counseling process. Imposing values can create a power dynamic that can make the counselee feel uncomfortable and less likely to open up about their issues. 


Focus on the Word of God and counsel in love, gentleness, and kindness.  


3. Do not pressure the counselee to make a decision


Pressuring the counselee to decide during a pastoral counseling meeting can negatively impact the counseling process. It can lead to the counselee feeling rushed or forced to make a decision that they may not be ready for or comfortable with.


Instead, a good approach is to provide guidance and support to help the counselee decide independently. This can involve active listening, asking open-ended questions, and providing resources for further reflection.


4. Do not use religion to cure mental illness


While pastoral counseling can be a valuable resource for individuals seeking support for mental health issues, it is essential to note that religion should not be relied upon as the sole cure for mental illness.


Mental health professionals, including pastoral counselors, should integrate evidence-based therapeutic techniques to provide effective treatment. Relying solely on religious beliefs and practices may not address the root cause of mental health issues and may even exacerbate symptoms.


It is crucial for individuals seeking pastoral counseling to work with a trained mental health professional who can provide a holistic approach to care. This is not to say you should not pray for healing but ensure all options are on the table.


5. Do not treat the counselee like a project


It’s important to remember that the person you’re counseling is not a project to be fixed but someone experiencing trouble in their life and may be struggling spiritually. One way to avoid treating the counselee like a project is to actively listen to what they’re saying without interrupting or jumping to conclusions. 


Ask open-ended questions to encourage them to share more and validate their feelings by acknowledging their perspective. Avoid giving unsolicited advice and guide them towards finding their solutions. 


6. Do not share details of the counseling session without permission


Maintaining confidentiality is crucial in pastoral counseling sessions as it builds trust and fosters a safe and secure environment for clients to share their personal experiences. Breaching confidentiality may result in severe consequences, including legal action, loss of reputation, and emotional harm to the client. 


To handle situations where disclosure may be necessary, obtaining the client’s consent or seeking legal authorization is advisable. 


7. Do not interrupt the counselee when he or she is speaking


During a pastoral counseling meeting, it is essential to avoid interrupting the counselee to ensure effective communication and understanding. Here are some tips to prevent interrupting:


  1. Listen actively: Pay attention to what the counselee is saying and avoid thinking about your response while they are still speaking.
  2. Maintain eye contact: This will help you to stay focused on the conversation and avoid distractions.
  3. Use nonverbal cues: Nodding, smiling, and other nonverbal cues can show that you are listening and encourage the counselee to continue sharing.
  4. Wait for pauses: Allow the counselee to finish their thought before responding. Wait for natural breaks in the conversation to avoid interrupting.
  5. Ask clarifying questions: If unsure about something the counselee said, ask for clarification instead of interrupting to avoid misunderstanding.


8. Do not use psychological techniques without a license


Pastoral counselors must avoid using psychological techniques without a license during counseling sessions because it can potentially harm the client. Pastoral counselors are not trained to diagnose or treat mental health disorders.


Using assessment tools without proper training and certification can lead to inaccurate diagnoses and inappropriate treatments. Additionally, pastoral counselors who engage in unlicensed psychological practices may be held liable for any harm caused to their clients. 


9. Do not use physical contact to establish rapport


Pastoral Counselors are expected to adhere to strict ethical standards, including refraining from using physical contact to establish rapport during counseling sessions. This is because physical touch can be misinterpreted, leading to boundary violations and potential harm to the client/patient.


Physical touch can be triggering for some individuals who have experienced sexual trauma or have personal boundaries around touch. As such, it is considered best practice for Pastoral Counselors to establish rapport through verbal communication and active listening rather than physical contact.


10. Do not flatter or deceive the counseled


During a pastoral counseling meeting, it is essential to avoid flattery or deception to build a trusting relationship with the counselee. Here are some tips to avoid these behaviors:


  1. Be honest: Being frank with the counselee about your qualifications, experience, and counseling process is crucial. Do not make false promises or exaggerate your abilities or success rates.
  2. Avoid flattery: Flattery can create a false sense of security and trust. It is essential to avoid excessive praise or compliments that may not be genuine.
  3. Do not solicit testimonials: Soliciting testimonials from current clients or vulnerable individuals can be seen as manipulative and unethical.
  4. Do not deceive: Deception can cause harm to the counselee and damage the counseling relationship. Be transparent about the counseling process and any potential risks or limitations.
  5. Protect confidentiality: Do not disclose confidential or personally identifiable information without the counselee’s written consent or legal authorization.
What Guidelines For Pastoral Counseling Insurance Do Insurance Companies Require?

What Guidelines For Pastoral Counseling Insurance Do Insurance Companies Require?

As church insurance agents, we must ensure the churches we present to church insurance companies follow best practices. Pastoral counselors must meet several guidelines to be eligible for insurance coverage:


  1. Churches must cooperate with other professionals and accurately report services provided and fees charged.
  2. Fee-based spiritual counseling must be consistent with state laws, and limitations to services must be discussed with clients early on. 
  3. Pastoral counselors must not engage in uninvited solicitation of business and must base payment on services provided rather than referrals.
  4. Education and training programs must have a current and accurate description of the program content.
  5. Background and reference checks are to be conducted on all spiritual counselors. 
  6. Establish written policies and procedures.
  7. One-on-one counseling should be done in an open and public space.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the legal requirements for pastoral counselors?


In contrast to clinical counseling or psychology, pastoral counselors are not required to obtain a license in most states. Instead, pastoral counselors must complete a certification process by their religious group and gain additional certification from a national organization such as the American Association of Pastoral Counselors. 


What are the ethical considerations for pastoral counselors?


As a pastoral counselor, it is vital to establish trust and uphold professional standards of conduct with clients. Respect the dignity and worth of all individuals, and protect their rights to privacy, confidentiality, and self-determination.


Safeguards may be necessary to protect vulnerable populations with impaired decision-making abilities. Be aware of cultural, individual, and role differences, and eliminate any biases affecting your work. 


What is the role of confidentiality in pastoral counseling?

Confidentiality is of utmost importance in pastoral counseling. Pastoral counselors are primarily obligated to protect the confidential information obtained through counseling activities.


They discuss the limits of confidentiality with their clients at the outset of the relationship and thereafter as new circumstances may warrant. Pastoral counselors maintain confidentiality in creating, storing, accessing, transferring, and disposing of records under their control.


Pastoral counselors may disclose confidential information only with appropriate consent or as mandated by law for a valid purpose. The importance of confidentiality lies in building trust and promoting effective counseling relationships with clients.


It helps clients to feel safe and secure in sharing their personal information and experiences with their counselors. Confidentiality also helps protect clients’ privacy and dignity, which are essential to the healing process in pastoral counseling.

Need Pastoral Counseling Professional Liability Insurance

Pastoral counselors need professional liability insurance coverage in today’s litigious society. Many individuals who seek counseling expect their counselors to have a high level of professional expertise and to be held accountable for their actions.


Unfortunately, mistakes can happen, and churches and religious organizations can sue for malpractice.


Pastoral counseling professional liability insurance from Integrity Now Insurance Brokers covers potential lawsuits arising from wrongful acts or omissions while providing spiritual counseling services. This type of insurance provides financial protection for pastoral counselors who may be held responsible for any damages resulting from their professional counseling services.


Working with a church insurance agency is essential to protect your local church with the right insurance coverage. By using an experienced church insurance agent, your church congregation will know they are insured correctly.


Integrity Now Insurance Brokers help churches obtain general liability insurance, property insurance, directors and officers coverage, abuse and molestation insurance, church auto insurance, workers’ comp insurance, and more.  


Contact us today for a free church insurance quote.

Recent Blogs

Accessibility Toolbar

Scroll to Top