Property Insurance for Churches

Property Insurance for Churches: How to Insure Small and Large Religious Organizations

Churches are essential community resources that can offer members a sense of identity and belonging and provide valuable services to the broader population. As such, churches must be adequately insured to protect against potential risks.


While property insurance for churches may seem daunting, there are a few key things to keep in mind that will simplify the process.


Here we will discuss what you need to know to adequately insure your church while properly containing your overall insurance costs.

What is Property Insurance For Churches?

Property insurance for churches is commercial building insurance that covers physical damage or destruction to the church’s real and business personal property, such as its buildings, structures, and contents. This insurance covers weather-related damage, equipment breakdown, food contamination, fine arts, trees, and sewer water backup coverage.


Reading through the policy to ensure it meets the church’s needs is essential, as many policies may exclude specific perils, such as floods and earthquakes. Property insurance is also vital to protect the church’s investment in the ministry and to ensure they are covered in the event of a fire or other incident.


Property insurance includes auto insurance coverage, which would provide security for damages to the church’s vehicles or injured people. Working with an experienced church insurance agency is critical as they have access to specialty insurance companies.

What Things You Should Consider When Getting Property Insurance For Churches?

1. Church Building Insurance Coverage Amount

Church building insurance coverage is the amount of money a church needs to insure its building, contents, and any other property the church owns against potential damage or loss. It is crucial to determine the value of the building, including any items permanently attached to it, such as sound systems, video projectors, and appliances, as well as the cost to replace or rebuild the facilities with contract labor and new materials.


Churches should also consider the amount of coverage they need concerning the coinsurance rate set by their insurance provider, typically 80, 90, and 100 percent of the property value.


2. Church Insurance Providers

When selecting church insurance, it’s essential to consider the different types of providers and the different coverage needs of your church. Several providers offer church insurance, ranging from specialized providers to large national insurers.


Working with a church insurance broker allows nonprofit religious organizations to obtain competitive insurance quotes from the best church insurance companies.


3. Stained Glass Windows Insurance Coverage

Church stained glass windows require specialized insurance coverage to be adequately protected. Churches need liability insurance or church fellowship insurance to cover the church from lawsuits arising from events or operations and coverage for messages and beliefs held.


Traditional insurance policies may not cover claims correctly related to stained glass windows as the glass insurance coverage only contemplates basic glass coverage. A stained glass window can cost a few hundred dollars to well over a million dollars to replace.


Churches and religious organizations need insurance to protect their house of worship, including specialized stained glass windows insurance coverage.


4. Religious Building Type

When evaluating property insurance for churches, several factors should be considered. The first factor to consider is the type of religious building. Churches can have different types of facilities, such as a church sanctuary, a fellowship hall, an outer structure, or a church school.


Each of these buildings will have different types of property that need to be insured, such as furniture, fixtures, and equipment. It’s essential to understand the needs of each building and to make sure the property insurance covers all of the property within.


Depending on the age of the building, older churches may require significantly higher building insurance coverage versus new or more modern church buildings. Integrity Now Insurance Brokers can access old church insurance programs and insurance companies that protect modern church buildings.


5. Religious Organization Insurance Plan

Church insurance is essential to any religious institution’s risk management plan. Church insurance plans provide churches coverage for property damage, liability claims, employee injury, and other risks associated with running a church.


These plans can be tailored to meet the specific needs of a church, such as the size and type of congregation and the amount of risk associated with activities and events.


A church insurance plan is vital for churches because it can help protect their financial stability. In the event of an accident or lawsuit, the church could draw on the insurance policy to help cover any costs associated with the incident. Without insurance, a church would be forced to pay out of pocket for any damages or legal fees, which could quickly deplete its resources.


6. Ministry Liability Insurance Coverage Limits

Church liability coverage limits are essential for getting property insurance for churches because they determine the amount of money that can be claimed in case of a lawsuit or other legal action.


Generally, churches should carry at least one million dollars in general liability coverage to protect them from financial hardship if they are sued. This coverage will cover a church from lawsuits filed due to bodily injury, property damage, or defense costs if they get into court proceedings.


Churches should also consider an umbrella policy for catastrophic liability events that a church could face.


7. Flood Insurance Program for Churches

A flood insurance program for churches is an important program that provides churches with financial protection against losses incurred due to flooding. This program offers coverage for both physical damages to the church building and additional living expenses incurred by the church, such as temporary meeting halls.


This type of insurance is significant for churches located in areas prone to flooding, as it can help them recover more quickly from any unexpected damage caused by a flood.


8. Earthquake Insurance

Earthquake insurance is vital for churches, as it can protect from costly damages resulting from earthquakes. Earthquake insurance can cover property damage to buildings, such as stained glass windows, fences, and signs, as well as indirect losses, such as business income losses and extra expenses resulting from an interruption in operations.


9. Sound Equipment Insurance Coverage for Churches

Sound equipment insurance coverage helps churches cover the cost of replacing sound equipment if it is damaged or destroyed by an unexpected event, such as a natural disaster or theft. Churches can be a target of thieves looking to obtain a piece of expensive sound equipment.

The Best Insurance Companies for Property Insurance For Churches

The Best Insurance Companies for Property Insurance For Churches

1. Philadelphia Insurance Company

Philadelphia Insurance Company is an excellent choice for property insurance for churches because it offers an inclusive package policy including Property, General Liability, Professional Liability, Abuse or Molestation, Third-Party Crime, Inland Marine, and Non-owned and Hired Auto so that churches can protect themselves from a wide range of exposures.


Philadelphia insurance is specifically tailored for large church organizations due to the coverage extension they include.


2. Great American Insurance Company

Great American Insurance Company is an excellent choice for property insurance for churches due to its financial stability, comprehensive coverage, and additional services. With an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best, Great American has a solid financial foundation and provides peace of mind to its policyholders.


Great American is also designed for larger churches and can provide an umbrella policy to provide additional coverage protection related to abuse and molestation coverage.


3. GuideOne Insurance Company

GuideOne Insurance Company is an excellent choice for property insurance for churches due to their comprehensive FaithGuard package, which is tailored specifically to religious organizations and provides customized coverage to the individual congregation and their particular needs.


GuideOne Insurance is an excellent choice for both small church insurance programs and large church insurance plans.


4. Church Mutual Insurance Company

Church Mutual Insurance Company is an excellent choice for property insurance for churches due to its specialized expertise and focuses on religious organizations. They have provided insurance for churches and other religious institutions since 1897 and are financially stable with an A (Excellent) rating from AM Best.


Church Mutual liability insurance will protect your place of worship against losses again and is an excellent choice for small and medium size churches.


Insurance is important for churches to have in place to protect them from issues that specifically arise from their operations. Our church insurance agents help to get coverage. You need from all of these church insurance companies and others who specialize in churches insurance.

Small Church Property Insurance Coverage Recommendations

Small churches should consider the need for property and liability insurance for adequate protection. Integrity Now Insurance Brokers helps religious leaders with a church’s unique coverage requirements to ensure they are protected.


Small churches must protect their place of worship from property damage, liability claims, auto insurance, and workers’ compensation insurance. While small churches may struggle to pay their insurance premiums, they still need essential coverages like pastoral professional liability coverage and fire insurance for churches.


By working with our team of experts, we will help get the coverage to protect your place of worship from property damage and theft.

Large Church Property Insurance Coverage

Large Church Property Insurance Coverage

When choosing the appropriate large church property insurance coverage, there are a few critical recommendations.


  1. It is crucial to make sure that you have a Special Form Insurance Coverage
  2. Ensure your coverage is set to replacement cost or agreed value coverage
  3. Make sure church buildings are insured correctly
  4. Ensure the church insurance company provides coverage for Religious Expression Insurance.
  5. Increase Medical Expenses Limits to the maximum available option
  6. Include your workers’ comp policy within your umbrella coverage for added protection
  7. Lastly, make sure to read the exclusions in your policy carefully


Integrity Now Insurance Brokers provides quotes for large churches, including general liability coverage to protect your church leaders and members. We obtain several quotes from top-rated church insurance companies.

Frequently Asked Questions

What type of insurance coverage is available for churches?

When it comes to protecting a church from the financial hardship of potential risks, there are two main types of insurance available – property insurance and liability insurance. Property insurance covers risks to the property owned by the church, such as buildings and personal business property. Liability insurance, on the other hand, covers risks associated with the church’s actions, such as injuries or damage to a person’s property.


How do I obtain a quote for property insurance for my church?

When obtaining quotes for property insurance for churches, it is essential to follow the four steps.

  1. Determine what type of coverage you need for your church. This will depend on the specific needs of your ministry. The basic coverages include property, general liability, management liability (D&O coverage), sexual molestation, professional liability, and crime.
  2. Call a church insurance broker and compare multiple quotes from top carriers with one application.
  3. Our experienced agents will help determine the best coverage for your needs and any discounts your church qualifies for.
  4. Purchase the church insurance policy that best suits your church’s needs.


What is the process for filing a claim on my church’s property insurance policy?

Has your church experienced a property or liability loss? Here is how to file an insurance claim:


What kind of liability insurance is recommended for my church?

General liability insurance is the most recommended coverage for churches. In addition to general liability insurance, churches should consider additional liability coverage for specific incidents, such as Employment Practices Liability, Directors and Officers, Pastoral Counseling, Religious Expression insurance, workers’ comp, cyber liability, and automobile insurance.


How much does property insurance for churches cost?

Property insurance for churches can vary significantly in cost depending on various factors. It is best to contact one of our licensed insurance agents specializing in church insurance and request a quote.


What property does church insurance cover?

Church property insurance covers a variety of items, including the church building, fixtures, furnishings, landscaping, musical instruments, library property, communication systems, computer equipment, and fine arts.


What type of events does church insurance cover?

Church event insurance primarily covers special events such as bazaars, fall festivals, and weddings. These policies typically include general liability and property insurance coverage. Church insurance covers other youth events, such as summer camps and winter activities.

Looking For Property Insurance For Churches

Integrity Now Insurance Brokers is an excellent choice for those looking for property insurance for churches. They have a team of experienced experts who understand the unique needs of churches and can provide tailored coverage options to fit any budget.


Their church insurance policies cover the full range of risks related to owning and operating a church, including fire, theft, vandalism, natural disasters, and many others.


Furthermore, we have competitive rates and offer flexible payment plans to ensure you get the best value for your money.


With Integrity Now Insurance Brokers, you can be sure that your church is fully protected and safe from potential losses or damages.

Recent Blogs

Accessibility Toolbar

Scroll to Top